Comments: Jimmy Wales Reverses On New Yorker False Credentials, Asks Resignation

You think Jimmy Wales wasn't fully informed (didn't have enough of a clue) and committed an egregious failure to distinguish pseudonimity from fraud?

Either:

a) he didn't know that pseudonimity does not (by itself) constitute fraud, whereas lieing is fraudulent (when truth rather than fiction is expected), and we can forgive him.

Or:
b) he knows full well (and gambled the public didn't), and this is simple PR damage control (as you suggest).

Posted by Crosbie Fitch at March 3, 2007 10:12 AM

lying

Posted by Crosbie Fitch at March 3, 2007 10:17 AM

Whether Wales did the right thing for the right reasons or not, you still ought to acknowledge that it was the right decision.

Wikipedia's clearly a trainwreck -- I've stopped claiming otherwise. But in Jordan's specific case, assuming he's really out, Wales undid a really bad decision to keep a fabulist in its management.

Posted by Rogers Cadenhead at March 3, 2007 11:20 AM

Rogers, I'm not a very forgiving person. Perhaps a flaw in my nature. I find it hard to be generous when a statement still has a lot of falseness in it, even if that's a political necessity. I'm bad at politics.

Posted by Seth Finkelstein at March 3, 2007 11:39 AM